For this comparison, we’re looking specifically at Carnival and Royal Caribbean cruises in Australia, New Zealand and the South Pacific. Both offer contemporary, family-friendly cruising with plenty of dining, entertainment and activities onboard. Carnival has the stronger year-round Australian presence and delivers a more casual, value-focused experience, while Royal Caribbean operates seasonally in the region with larger ships, more headline attractions and a more resort-style onboard experience.
Carnival’s regional fleet includes Carnival Splendor, Carnival Luminosa, Carnival Adventure and Carnival Encounter, with a mix of pools, waterslides, entertainment, family activities and familiar resort-style facilities. Royal Caribbean currently deploys ships Anthem of the Seas, Ovation of the Seas and Quantum of the Seas in the region, with attractions depending on the vessel including FlowRider surf simulators, bumper cars, rock climbing, iFLY and the North Star observation capsule. Both cruise-lines are lively and family-focused, but Royal’s ships generally offer more high-profile attractions, while Carnival keeps the experience a little more casual and straightforward.
Both cater strongly for families, with dedicated youth programs, family accommodation and plenty for children and adults to enjoy together. Royal Caribbean’s Adventure Ocean program is complemented by a broad range of family attractions that varies by ship, while Carnival also offers age-based youth programs and plenty of family-focused facilities across its regional fleet. Royal generally offers more activity-driven family experiences onboard, while Carnival provides a simpler and often more relaxed family cruise style.
Both offer complimentary and specialty dining, live entertainment, pools, bars and daytime activities, but the emphasis differs. Carnival’s regional ships focus on a casual, sociable atmosphere, with Carnival Adventure and Carnival Encounter retaining some venues and experiences inherited from P&O Cruises Australia. Royal Caribbean’s ships generally offer more large-scale attractions and a broader range of onboard activities, although the exact experience varies considerably by vessel. The better fit will often come down to whether you prefer Carnival’s relaxed style or Royal’s more activity-packed resort approach.
Both offer relatively affordable base fares with accommodation, selected dining, entertainment and many onboard activities included, while alcohol, Wi-Fi, specialty dining and shore excursions cost extra. Carnival often has the lower starting price and uses Australian dollars onboard for cruises from Australia, while Royal Caribbean uses US dollars onboard. Royal may therefore cost more once extras and exchange rates are considered, although the additional attractions available on its ships can add value for travellers who plan to make the most of them.
Carnival has the stronger year-round presence in the region, with cruises from Sydney and Brisbane to destinations across Australia, New Zealand, the South Pacific, Fiji and Papua New Guinea, along with selected seasonal departures from other Australian and New Zealand ports. Royal Caribbean operates seasonally from Australia, with cruises through Australia, New Zealand and the South Pacific aboard Anthem, Ovation and Voyager of the Seas. Carnival offers more departure dates and greater year-round flexibility, while Royal provides a strong seasonal alternative with a different mix of ships and onboard experiences.
Compare Cruise Lines